Dispute about authorshipEdit

During its initial release on Original Sin, this track was credited to Jim Steinman, and due to its reuse, his authorship was never questioned. However, it has recently been discovered that this piece was actually written by noted author Ken Millar (writing pseudonymously as Ross A. MacDonald), who published it in his 1963 book The Chill. Steinman recently acclaimed MacDonald on his blog as one of the best mystery writers of all time.


These words can be found at the beginning of the script for Rhinegold.

Ellen Foley on Original Sin

The Dream Engine in various live performances


If light were dark and dark were light
The moon a black hole in the blaze of night
A raven's wing as bright as tin
Then you, my love
Would be darker than sin

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.